Fiyaz Mughal OBE - Supporting the development of mutual respect through our common values in communities is what drives me. Everyone should be able to live free from fear, intolerance and bigotry.
Sunday, 1 February 2015
Sunday, 4 January 2015
RE: Twitter and Facebook Refusing to Take Down Hundreds of Inflammatory anti-Muslim Postings
This is an article from the Front Cover of the Independent Newspaper for Saturday the 3rd of January 2015
Twitter and Facebook are refusing to take down hundreds of inflammatory Islamophobic postings from across their sites despite being alerted to the content by anti-racism groups, an investigation by The Independent has established.
The number of postings, some of which accuse Muslims of
being rapists, paedophiles and comparable to cancer, has increased
significantly in recent months in the aftermath of the Rotherham
sex-abuse scandal and the murder of British hostages held by Isis.
The most extreme call for the execution of British Muslims – but in most cases those behind the abuse have not had their accounts suspended or the posts removed.
Facebook said it had to “strike the right balance” between freedom of expression and maintaining “a safe and trusted environment” but would remove any content reported to it that “directly attacks others based on their race”. Twitter said it reviews all content that is reported for breaking its rules which prohibit specific threats of violence.
Over the past four months Muslim groups have been attempting to compile details of online abuse and report it to Twitter and Facebook. They have brought dozens of accounts and hundreds of messages to the attention of the social-media companies.
But despite this most of the accounts reported are still easily accessible. On New Year’s Eve the author of one of the accounts reported wrote: “If whites had groomed only paki girls 1 It would be a race hate crime. 2 There would be riots from all Muslim dogs.”
Other examples of extremist postings on Twitter include:
*A user posted an image of a girl with a noose around her neck with the caption: “6 per cent of white British girls will become sex slaves to the Islamic slave trade in Britain”.
*A tweet which reads: “Should have lost World War Two. Your daughters would be getting impregnated by handsome blond Germans instead of Pakistani goat herders. Good job Britain.”
*On Facebook a posting in response to the beheading of Westerners in Syria is also still easily accessible despite being reported to the company weeks ago. It reads: “For every person beheaded by these sick savages we should drag 10 off the streets and behead them, film it and put it online. For every child they cut in half … we cut one of their children in half. An eye for an eye.”
When the comments were reported, Facebook said that they did not breach the organisation’s guidelines.
Fiyaz Mughal, director of Faith Matters, an interfaith organisation which runs a helpline called Tell MAMA, for victims of anti-Muslim violence, said he was disappointed by the attitude of both firms.
“It is morally unacceptable that social media platforms like Facebook and Twitter, which are vast profit-making companies, socially engineer what is right and wrong to say in our society when they leave up inflammatory, highly socially divisive and openly bigoted views,” he said.
“These platforms have inserted themselves into our social fabric to make profit and cannot sit idly by and shape our futures based on ‘terms and conditions’ that are not fit for purpose.”
Mr Mughal said that Tell MAMA regularly received reports of anti-Muslim rhetoric and hate from concerned Facebook and Twitter users.
He added that the far-right group Britain First relied on Facebook to organise, campaign and misinform followers about Islam and Muslims.
The rise in online abuse would appear to mirror a rise in hate attacks during the past year. In October the Metropolitan Police released figures to show hate crime against Muslims in London had risen by 65 per cent over the previous 12 months. Latest figures also suggest that, nationally, anti-Muslim hate crime has risen sharply following the murder of Lee Rigby in 2013.
One man, Eric King, was recently given a suspended sentence for sending a local mosque a picture smeared with dog excrement depicting Mohamed having sex with a pig. However his Facebook account, which he used to send abusive messages to the same mosque, is still active and promoting anti-Muslim hatred.
Mr Mughal added that social media platforms needed to make their content management procedures stricter.
“If users were to express such unacceptable opinions about ‘shooting’ Black British citizens or discussed Jews as a ‘cancer’, their speech would not be legal. The same protections should be forwarded to references to the Muslim community,” he said.
In a statement Facebook said it had a clear policy for deciding what was and what was not acceptable freedom of speech. “We take hate speech seriously and remove any content reported to us that directly attacks others based on their race, ethnicity, national origin, religion, sex, gender, sexual orientation, disability or medical condition,” said a spokeswoman. “With a diverse global community of more than a billion people, we occasionally see people post content which, whilst not against our rules, some people may find offensive. By working with community groups like Faith Matters, we aim to show people the power of counter speech and, in doing so, strike the right balance between giving people the freedom to express themselves and maintaining a safe and trusted environment.”
A Twitter spokesman said: “We review all reported content against our rules, which prohibit targeted abuse and direct, specific threats of violence against others.”
The most extreme call for the execution of British Muslims – but in most cases those behind the abuse have not had their accounts suspended or the posts removed.
Facebook said it had to “strike the right balance” between freedom of expression and maintaining “a safe and trusted environment” but would remove any content reported to it that “directly attacks others based on their race”. Twitter said it reviews all content that is reported for breaking its rules which prohibit specific threats of violence.
Over the past four months Muslim groups have been attempting to compile details of online abuse and report it to Twitter and Facebook. They have brought dozens of accounts and hundreds of messages to the attention of the social-media companies.
But despite this most of the accounts reported are still easily accessible. On New Year’s Eve the author of one of the accounts reported wrote: “If whites had groomed only paki girls 1 It would be a race hate crime. 2 There would be riots from all Muslim dogs.”
Other examples of extremist postings on Twitter include:
*A user posted an image of a girl with a noose around her neck with the caption: “6 per cent of white British girls will become sex slaves to the Islamic slave trade in Britain”.
*A tweet which reads: “Should have lost World War Two. Your daughters would be getting impregnated by handsome blond Germans instead of Pakistani goat herders. Good job Britain.”
*On Facebook a posting in response to the beheading of Westerners in Syria is also still easily accessible despite being reported to the company weeks ago. It reads: “For every person beheaded by these sick savages we should drag 10 off the streets and behead them, film it and put it online. For every child they cut in half … we cut one of their children in half. An eye for an eye.”
When the comments were reported, Facebook said that they did not breach the organisation’s guidelines.
Fiyaz Mughal, director of Faith Matters, an interfaith organisation which runs a helpline called Tell MAMA, for victims of anti-Muslim violence, said he was disappointed by the attitude of both firms.
“It is morally unacceptable that social media platforms like Facebook and Twitter, which are vast profit-making companies, socially engineer what is right and wrong to say in our society when they leave up inflammatory, highly socially divisive and openly bigoted views,” he said.
“These platforms have inserted themselves into our social fabric to make profit and cannot sit idly by and shape our futures based on ‘terms and conditions’ that are not fit for purpose.”
Mr Mughal said that Tell MAMA regularly received reports of anti-Muslim rhetoric and hate from concerned Facebook and Twitter users.
He added that the far-right group Britain First relied on Facebook to organise, campaign and misinform followers about Islam and Muslims.
The rise in online abuse would appear to mirror a rise in hate attacks during the past year. In October the Metropolitan Police released figures to show hate crime against Muslims in London had risen by 65 per cent over the previous 12 months. Latest figures also suggest that, nationally, anti-Muslim hate crime has risen sharply following the murder of Lee Rigby in 2013.
One man, Eric King, was recently given a suspended sentence for sending a local mosque a picture smeared with dog excrement depicting Mohamed having sex with a pig. However his Facebook account, which he used to send abusive messages to the same mosque, is still active and promoting anti-Muslim hatred.
“If users were to express such unacceptable opinions about ‘shooting’ Black British citizens or discussed Jews as a ‘cancer’, their speech would not be legal. The same protections should be forwarded to references to the Muslim community,” he said.
In a statement Facebook said it had a clear policy for deciding what was and what was not acceptable freedom of speech. “We take hate speech seriously and remove any content reported to us that directly attacks others based on their race, ethnicity, national origin, religion, sex, gender, sexual orientation, disability or medical condition,” said a spokeswoman. “With a diverse global community of more than a billion people, we occasionally see people post content which, whilst not against our rules, some people may find offensive. By working with community groups like Faith Matters, we aim to show people the power of counter speech and, in doing so, strike the right balance between giving people the freedom to express themselves and maintaining a safe and trusted environment.”
A Twitter spokesman said: “We review all reported content against our rules, which prohibit targeted abuse and direct, specific threats of violence against others.”
Thursday, 18 September 2014
We Should Stand With the Prime Minister in Tackling the Threat From ISIS
The prime minster needs the support of Muslim communities in the struggle against ISIS
After the recent brutal murder of aid worker David Haines, the prime
minister issued a statement that once again made clear the distinction
between Islam as a peaceful religion followed by many productive and
peaceful citizens in the UK and those extremists roaming in Syria and
Iraq, chasing minorities and destroying the heritage of these groups.
The prime minister has repeatedly set out this position time and time
again, not only because it is accurate and true, but also because a
clear line has been to be drawn between those in ISIS and Muslim
communities globally.
The dividing line between law abiding Muslims and those brutal
murderers in ISIS is essential to keep cementing for two key reasons.
The first is that it undermines the corrosive narratives of far-right
and other anti-Muslim groups who try to amalgamate every Muslim into an
amorphous mass of people who are collectively a threat to Europe and the
West.
Whilst this narrative may seem devoid of reality, the sad truth is
that it has resonated in some sections of communities, particularly with
young disaffected white males, who in many instances, are socially
excluded.
Secondly, by doing so, the prime minister has drawn a much needed
line between the slick propaganda of ISIS and Muslim communities in our
country so that the pull of these extremists is actively challenged.
Yet, there is something that is troubling and worrying. Whilst many
Muslim civil society groups, mosques and Imams have roundly condemned
the murder of David Haines, the troubling factor is that there will have
been pressures on the prime minister to push harder for greater legal
anti-terrorism measures. These no doubt, would have impacts on civil
liberties and with a possible disproportionate impact on Muslim
communities.
The realpolitik is that the prime minster is juggling between those
who want him to get much tougher on domestic and international extremism
and terrorism; yet what is clear is that the prime minister has not
lost sight of one key factor. The way to challenge and address such
extremism and rhetoric is through one key asset, in this case British
Muslim communities.
This is the message the prime minister is repeatedly putting out time and time again and which should not be forgotten.
The prime minister’s position should be welcomed and shored up by
Muslim communities, irrespective of their views on other political
matters. On the issue of tackling extremism, his support for Muslim
communities as an asset in the ideological battle means we have a prime
minister who believes in a Britain where young Muslims have a future;
his vision is of a pluralistic Britain where communities are free to
live their lives from fear and where threats to our country must be
mitigated against by a pro-active stance against groups like ISIS.
All of this is welcome, yet if this opportunity is not grasped by the leadership in Muslim communities the future looks bleak.
Yet all indicators are showing religious leaders, civil society
activists and social change makers in British Muslim communities coming
together to collectively reject the ideology of ISIS.
The reality is that in Europe today, the forces of far-right groups are growing. A recent poll in France
indicated that the National Front’s Marine Le Pen would win the
presidential race for France if a snap election were held now. The far-right Swedish Democrats
have just polled double figures in the Swedish elections making them
potential kingmakers in a future cabinet. Both groups have focused their
target on Muslim communities and on immigration, making their politics
toxic for future integration and for cohesion in these countries.
Britain still stands as a bastion for pluralism in a Europe where
extreme parties couched in populist language elbow forward for seats of
power. Our government and our prime minister still hold dear to the view
that all communities have a future in Britain, unlike the National
Front or Swedish Democrats who look on Muslim communities as being
‘problematic,’ a view that is soaked up by those in France and Sweden
who cannot find employment and who look for easy answers and for someone
to blame for their shortfalls.
A further lurch to the right in Britain, on the back of rhetoric
suggesting that Muslim communities are unable to integrate and who are
potential security threats, has the potential of a domino effect across
the continent which will have resounding impacts on Europe and the
countries of the Mediterranean with large Muslim populations.
Whilst a ‘clash of civilisations’ will not, thankfully, happen, a
widening political divide between Europe and Mediterranean countries
bodes ill for future trade, geo-political and military alliances.
European nations may think that they are countries of tolerance and
understanding, but it is Britain that is an influencing factor in
ensuring they maintain their stance. Our ideals and our values set a
trail that many countries have tried to emulate with civil servant after
civil servant from these countries coming to the UK to find out how we
‘do’ pluralism.
Which brings me back to the core point that the prime minster needs
the support of Muslim communities in this struggle against ISIS and in
dissuading young people to go to Syria or Iraq. It is a call that we
must heed, not only because it is the right thing to do, but because a
weakening of the prime minister’s position will have dire consequences
for those who believe in a liberal and pluralist Europe.
Now is the time to tackle a group like ISIS – one of the greatest
threats to Muslim and non-Muslim communities, as well as to the Middle
East and Europe. Not since the end of the Cold War has such an issue
arisen. Now is not the time to wobble and to back away from a prime
minister who, on this issue, has done the right thing.
Monday, 15 September 2014
A Chief Rabbi-Type Figure in Muslim Communities May Well Be Part of the Solution
Having worked with faith communities for well over a decade now,
there are strengths within all faith groups and there are, it has to be
noted, some structural weaknesses within them. The de-centralised nature
of advocacy and faith leadership within Sikh, Hindu and Muslim
communities means that localism has been a strong part of faith
leadership and to some degree, local communities are able to relate to,
engage with and fully understand their local faith leaders. Such
localism no doubt resonates beyond these faith communities and into
political policies and it provides a degree of variance and flexibility
to the variety of voices that speak for and advocate on issues related
to these faiths.
Yet, whilst these localised networks may have
worked well in the by-gone pre-digital age, (before the Internet and
twenty-four hour news networks), they are unable to develop a coherent
voice on issues that are some of the most pressing in the global
political arena today. For example, one of the charges that are levelled
at Muslim communities has been, 'who speaks for Muslim communities?'
Others have stated that 'Muslims do not speak out when terrorism is
undertaken in their name.' This latter charge, it must be noted, usually
comes from those who seek to blame Muslim communities as a whole, which
in itself is ludicrous as though a British Muslim in Manchester is
responsible for the actions of a group like Isis. There are others who
also make the latter charge, who truly believe that Muslims do not speak
out enough, yet, blissfully unaware that what has developed are a
coterie of 'go to people' with comments on Muslim communities, with
little or no community traction or theological understanding of Islam.
Which
brings us back to the core thrust of this piece. One of the strengths
of communities is when they have some form of authority figure who can
speak out, with the backing of members of that community. Whilst the
impact of messaging from such a figure may have to compete with others
in a digital age where comments and blog pieces usually create a haze
around what is relevant or truthful, it can nonetheless be a voice of
reason with some gravitas and relevance.
For example, the Chief
Rabbi - Ephraim Mervis, is a great example of how a leadership role can
help to shape opinion and inform people. The Chief Rabbi's comments
and thoughts on anti-Semitism after the recent Gaza crisis hammered
home the fears within Jewish communities about anti-Semitism and the
spike that the Community Security Trust
had reported. What Muslim communities lack, is some form of religious
authority who can also speak from an informed position which is fed into
by various Muslim communities. On issues of anti-Muslim bigotry, for
example, a counter-part within Muslim communities to Ephraim Mervis
would help to get the message across that anti-Muslim bigotry, like
other forms of hate and intolerance, is unacceptable in our society.
The
last time that a Muslim equivalent was talked about, was during the
time of the late Dr Zaki Badawi. Those discussions seemed to fall away
after his death and need to be rekindled at a time of difficult
pressures on British Muslim communities when national and international
events are projected onto all British Muslims by virtue of their
co-religionists. It is time that a Chief Imam or Grand Mufti be
appointed from within Muslim communities who can also undertake similar
duties to the Chief Rabbi and this has also been raised by Parliamentarians.
Eric Ollerenshaw MP recently made the case and re-iterated the need for
a Grand Mufti for Great Britain, citing the example of the Grand Mufti
of Bosnia.
As long as Muslim communities do not have the
equivalent to a Chief Rabbi, sadly, there will be a space in the social
sphere which will be filled by those who are less interested in the
welfare of Muslim communities, and more interested in making a name for
themselves. Now is the time to grab this challenge with both hands.
Monday, 26 May 2014
European Results Show a Collapse in Liberal Democrat Support
It seems that two parties on polar ends of the political spectrum on Europe have been the losers and winners in the EU elections. UKIP romped home with major gains across the regions whilst the Liberal Democrat vote failed to shore up or even turn out in any force. The result was a Liberal Democrat cache of 1 seat and no doubt with plenty of disgruntled ex-MEP's and councillors who may well turn against the leadership of the Party.
Many Liberal Democrat activists are social democrats and social progressives. Many feel that there is a gulf between the leadership and between members and some Liberal Democrat supporters also moved away from the Party when the decision was made to go into Coalition with the Conservatives. Yet, there is a growing sense of discontentment that the Liberal Democrat leadership must take into account and address, and quickly.
The loss of council seats and the corresponding loss of MEP seats will no doubt strengthen the campaign asking for a change of leadership within the Liberal Democrats. However, it is clear that the Liberal Democrats will not be ditching their leader and Nick Clegg will be leading the Party, however battered, into the next election. This is the only way forward since ditching a leader who has held the Coalition together would really be committing suicide at such a sensitive time as the Parliamentary elections loom over the horizon.
Support for the European project has been a key flagship policy for the Liberal Democrats and the wipe out in the results this evening means that the Party needs to reflect and act quickly. Their message on Europe failed to move the general public and also has given the wider public the impression that they may fast be becoming irrelevant. This would be a disaster for British politics since the Liberal Democrats have been and will be a force for change as social progressives and social democrats.
Whatever the future holds, now is the time for the Party to dig deep, regroup, support the Party machinery and hold its nerve whilst promoting its progressive politics to our country. Doing any less will surely lead to further defeats at the General Election.
Monday, 19 May 2014
TIMOTHY MARTIN BURTON FROM THE WEST MIDLANDS AGAIN
Last Thursday, I highlighted the case of Timothy Martin Burton who targeted me for over 10 months because of my perceived faith. Here are full details of the targeting that took place, by Burton.
However, here is some background that has come to light on Timothy Martin Burton aka @catstrangler101
2013 article about HuT:
“First
of all, I would like to reiterate that there is NO SUCH THING as Islamo-phobia.
Islam, as a totalitarian political ideology, seeks to overthrow and destroy all
Western Governments and societies based on Judaeo-Christian principles, which
arguably represent the best framework to date for the advancement of humanity,
not only for our generation, but for subsequent generations, and that framework
is undeniably superior – on EVERY measurable scale - to anything that Islam has
to offer. The religious aspects of Islam are of no interest to non-Muslims, but
to be concerned about the effects of the political ideology of Islam on our
civilisation is not Islamo-phobia, it is Islamo-REALISM.”
2013 article: In defence of the English
Defence League:
“Despite
all this, the EDL continues to represent the views of many common people like
myself who believe that the unrestricted, uncontrolled presence of a large
Muslim population in ANY Western country poses a significant danger to national
security. An unbiased look at their website is sufficient, in my view, to
demonstrate that the EDL is in no way a "hate group" and is in no way
racist or bigoted in the point of view they seek to get across to reasonable
people. There is a HUGE problem, not with individual Muslims who, as I have
often said, are generally charming and courteous, but with the political
ideology of Islam, which seeks to subjugate us all under the barbaric rules of
Sharia Law, which necessarily includes the suppression of freedom of speech,
(as demonstrated by the support of the 25000 Muslims who turned out in
Birmingham in late April) and which hides behind the cloak of religion to
promote its totalitarian agenda of world domination.”
“My
last thoughts on this subject include a way in which the EDL could perhaps make
itself more effective. In the US recently, the American Freedom Defence
Initiative (AFDI, in conjunction with SION - Stop the Islamisation of Nations)
produced an 18-point platform for a sane, sensible set of policies which
freedom-loving groups in every Western country would do well to consider for
adoption as follows:
E.g,
Surveillance of mosques and regular inspections of mosques in the U.S. and
other non-Muslim nations to look for pro-violence materials. Any mosque
advocating jihad or any aspects of Sharia that conflict with Constitutional
freedoms and protections should be closed.”
Klout profile of @catstrangler101 (includes
some abusive tweets)
2012 tweet about Islam being a murderous
ideology
Burton
wrote
a long response to Tommy Robinson leaving the EDL:
“Not
to mention, of course, that the EDL are labelled as “far right extremists” when
in fact they represent the centre ground of concerned indigenous British
citizens of all cultures. By the way, for those of you on the left who are so
fond of portraying the EDL as racists - this is nothing whatsoever to do with
race or with the colour of one’s skin – it is a natural response by
freedom-loving patriots which has been forced on us through the negligent
actions of, or by the complicity of our political elites, against the
totalitarian, supremacist political ideology of Islam which threatens the
entire world today – an ideology which is every bit as nasty, pervasive and
evil today as Nazism was when it threatened the entire world seventy years
ago.”
Burton
is part of a counter-Jihad blog titled ‘Freedom Loving Infidel’ also has a co.uk
link.
Burton
has posted pieces on Eurabia, Geert Wilders and ‘Islamisation by birth rate’ – or reposting content from Jihad Watch (2008).
It cites among must read links: Jihad Watch, Bare Naked Islam, Dhimmi Watch,
Archbishop Cramer, Pat Condell, Infidel Bloggers Alliance, Daniel Pipes.
An
unconfirmed YouTube account (with the same name) posted this racist comment:
“I've
got nothing against niggers, I think every home should have one.”
Other
comments on the YouTube account discuss Islam.
This
link suggests Burton had posted various comments on stories on sites
like Jihad Watch.
Linked
to EDL Radio
Example of Wordpress coments
Posted the EDL logo to his Facebook in 2013
Burton
is also a member of the Canada Defence League Facebook page
Example of Jihad Watch comment (2010):
“So
what will it take for the US to recognise that we have a maliciously-motivated
fifth column living amongst us? Another 9/11, multiplied by hundreds or
thousands thanks to the wonders of nuclear bomb-making technology disseminated
to Muslim countries?
My
two cents:
Stop
Muslim immigration and prevent any further mosque building.
Citizenship
to be dependent on NOT being a Muslim.
Disbar
any Muslim now here from serving in public office in any capacity – especially any
political / armed forces / police capacity.
Commence
a program of Muslim repatriation and mosque sequestration / demolition.
It
would be cheaper in terms of blood and treasure compared to what is coming down
the pike.
Catstrangler
101. Not a cat. Not a strangler. Not 101.”
Thursday, 15 May 2014
Timothy Martin Burton, aka 'M-CAT' @catstrangler101 and the Targeted Campaign
The Tweets
Over the last 10 months I have been
subjected to a hate campaign that involved a West Midlands based Timothy Martin
Burton, who through a variety of accounts, targeted me because of my faith and
on the back of a series of articles highlighting the TELL MAMA Islamophobic
monitoring project. Whilst Timothy Martin Burton’s @catstrangler101 account was
reported to the local police and through ACPO (Association of Chief Police
Officer) contacts, no action was taken even though multiple tweets were targeted at TELL MAMA (of which I am the Director) and which specifically named me. It was at this point
where we decided to act and information was provided by TELL MAMA to West
Midlands Police which linked Timothy Martin Burton to the @catstrangler101 M-CAT
account that had over 6,000 Twitter followers, many of them Far Right
sympathisers. A look at this account provided us with an insight into the mind-set
of Timothy Martin Burton when we found a tweet from the 18th of May 2012 which
read:
"#ThingsWeAskGod2HelpUsWith
- Getting rid of all the inbred, parasitic, welfare scrounging Muslim
paedophiles out of our country for a start."
The campaign against me was triggered
off after an Andrew Gilligan article that was written in the Telegraph on the 2nd
of June 2013. The
subsequent campaign by Timothy Martin Burton went onto March 2014 and was conducted
by Burton through Twitter and through a number of Far Right and extremist
web-sites that crossed the United States, the UK and Australia. In one of the
postings on a bizarre and virulently anti-Muslim Australian focussed web-site,
Timothy Martin Burton stated, "Excellent
post Mike, and I shall be reposting it far and wide, a strategy that will no
doubt include the hire of an enormous billboard situated right outside Fiyaz
Mughal's office window." We will come onto the statements made by that
article and by Mike Holt, the owner of the site. In fact, a quick look at the
site shows a campaign to donate to the Restore Australia web-site to ban the
Bendingo Mosque campaign in Australia. Hardly impartial, the Restore Australia
project is a patchwork quilt of xenophobic, anti-Muslim and extreme comments
and articles.
So, what were the targeted tweets that
were aimed at us? On the 2nd of June 2013, we received the following tweet
after the Gilligan article went live on the Telegraph web-site. It was
addressed to @tellmamauk, the Twitter address for the anti-Muslim hate crime
monitoring project and also included the English Defence League Twitter
address. Coming from Timothy Martin Burton it read:
"@Official_EDL,
@tellmamauk: Let's stick it to that mendacious taquiyya (sic) artist Fiyaz
Mughal."
For those not aware of the meaning of
the word 'Taqiyya', we have listed the context and the
meaning in this previous article. Clearly, in this context, the term
was used to suggest that I, because of my faith, lied to spread, protect or
further Islam. The narrative is virtually identical to the twisted anti-Semitism
of Far Right groups who see Jews as maliciously wanting to subvert the
Christian West by taking over positions of assumed power. In this context, it
was targeted at me, because of my faith.
On the 3rd of June 2013, I received
another tweet from an account named FreedomLovin'Terrier @ardentadmirer1. It
read as:
"Breaking
News @tellmamauk: Mendacious Muslim scumbag Fiyaz Mughal agrees not to tell any
more porkies if UK Gov't give him back his £214,000 back." We believed this to be Timothy Martin
Burton given the use of the same vocabulary in the tweet.
Again on the 3rd of June 2013, we
received a further tweet from Timothy Martin Burton's @catstrangler101 M-CAT
account which stated the following:
"#MyJihad
- the taqqiyya (sic) by @tellmamauk about the 'wave of attacks on Muslims'
after the Woolwich Islamic murder." A link was also attached to this tweet directed at us in
TELL MAMA and naming me and isolating me out for my faith because of the
taqiyya suggestion.
Once again on the 3rd of June, Timothy
Martin Burton sent us another tweet from his M-CAT @catstrangler101 account
which stated:
"@tellmamauk
- I wish to report Fiyaz Mughal for being a mendacious, grievance-mongering
little Muslim scumbag and I want my £214,000 back." These tweets were retweeted by a
coterie of Far Right activists on-line.
On the 9th of June Timothy Martin
Burton's M-CAT @catstrangler101 account went into action again and he targeted
me specifically again. It read as:
"#MyJihad
- Thanks to M-CAT, the mendacious little scumbag Fiyaz Mughal @tellmamauk has
had his funding withdrawn."
The tweet ended with a link and was referenced to another article written
by Andrew Gilligan which asserted that our funding had been withdrawn
because TELL MAMA had, according to the Telegraph, overplayed the backlash against Muslim communities and which we had previously challenged in TELL MAMA. However, what is clear is that after the murder of Lee Rigby, there was a sharp rise in anti-Muslim hate incidents and crimes and these can be further triangulated here and here. I don't choose to go over the whole debate since this matter is now in the past and TELL MAMA and the work that we do must move forward for the sake of the people that we are helping - victims of anti-Muslim hatred.
Timothy Martin Burton continued with
his hate campaign stating in a tweet on the 15th of June 2013 through the M-CAT
@catstrangler101 account:
"#FamousMuslimQuotes
- "Yes infidel, Islam has always been at the forefront of medical
technology. Now shut up and drink this camel piss."
He carried on with a further tweet to
the 6,000 plus followers and to the Twitter-sphere saying:
"#MyJihad
Hey kuffar! Fed up with Islam? Don't like your Muslim neighbours? Mosque in
your area causing a problem? Call 1-800-DRONE-STRIKE now!" Two references were made here and the
first being a twist on the use of the #MyJihad hashtag which was being used by
some Muslim Twitter users to take away the violent nature of the assumptions of
the word and the latter was a reference to the drone strikes conducted
in a few Muslim majority countries, such as Pakistan. Burton was using this as a way of further inflaming
sentiments within Muslim communities.
On the 18th of June 2013, Timothy
Martin Burton, again through the now infamous M-CAT @catstrangler101 account
tweeted the following:
"FYI I don't like having to refer to Muslims as
shit-for-brains, but indoctrination with Islam removes capacity for
constructive thinking."
On the 19th of June 2013,
Timothy Martin Burton went onto tweet the following:
“#MyJihad
– Not all Muslims are terrorists, paedophiles, retarded fuckwits our pushy
little inbred welfare parasites with shit for brains.”
“@Little_Otto
– Unfortunately I am restrained by the 140 char limit but I think we can safely
say that misogyny is a defining characteristic.” This tweet referred to Muslims.
“@ellierogerz
@SarveshKrDev – At the end of the day, Islamic ideology is not just an
alternative viewpoint. It IS pure, unmitigated evil.”
So prolific was Timothy Martin Burton
on Twitter that he decided to contact us at the beginning of September 2013.
Through a separate account, which we believed to be his, he tweeted through
@Muhammadtehpig (sic):
“#My
Jihad – the Taqqiyya by @tellmamauk about the wave of attacks on Muslims after
the Woolwich Islamic murder.”
The tweet was identical to the one sent to us on the 3rd of June
2013 through his M-CAT @catstrangler101 account. So here was Burton using
another account which he described as, “the Sous Chef of Allah’s Snackbar.
Signature dishes include bacon and pork sausages. BBQ’d over a bed of burning
Qu’rans for that special charcoal flavour. #TGDN #TCOT.”
In fact, from that same account, 7
minutes later he targeted us at TELL MAMA again with the following tweet:
“Breaking
News @tellmamauk Mendacious Muslim Scumbag Fiyaz Mughal agrees not to tell any
more porkies if UK Govt give him back his £214,000.” This tweet was not only identical in
its nature to the one on the 3rd of June 2013 sent from another
account we believe was associated with him (@ardentadmirer1), it also listed
monies identical in amount to the ones emanating from his infamous @catstrangler101
account. In fact a further set of tweets were sent and targeted at TELL MAMA
which went on until the 22nd of September 2013.
The Arrest of Timothy Martin Burton
Timothy Martin Burton was finally
arrested by West-Midlands police after we within TELL MAMA made the case of a
direct link to the @catstrangler101 account. Timothy Martin Burton was bailed on the proviso that no contact was
made with myself. Part of this assumption was that he would not contact the
@tellmamauk Twitter address, yet on the 18th of January 2014 Timothy
Martin Burton was active again on Twitter. The following tweet again
demonstrated his views of Muslims or ‘Mohammedans’ as he called them. This came
through his @catstrangler101 account:
“#MyJihad – Apologies for using ‘Mohammeddans’ in my previous post when what I meant was – terrorist, paedophiles and inbred welfare parasites.”
Timothy Martin Burton followed this
tweet with one on the 1st of March 2014, some 5 weeks before the
trial at Birmingham Magistrate’s court. From the usual @catstrangler101 account
it stated:
“Threatening
arrests over a tweet – the mendacious grievance-mongering taqqiyya (sic)
artists @tellmamauk are at it again.”
So not only did he breach his bail conditions, Timothy Martin Burton continued
to target and promote anti-Muslim hate publicly and openly on the Twitter
platforms, including us at TELL MAMA knowing that I would probably come across
the material as the Director of the project.
Links to Far Right Sites
Over the course of 2013, we had provided
significant evidence to West-Midlands police as to internet links that Timothy
Martin Burton had with Robert Spencer in the US. One of the doyennes of the
virulently anti-Muslim so called counter-Jihad network, Robert Spencer has been banned from
entering the UK by the Home Secretary.
A further appeal also failed and the initial letter from the Home
Office to the anti-Muslim blogger Robert Spencer read,
"After careful consideration, she [the Home Secretary] personally directed that you should be excluded from the United Kingdom on the grounds that your presence here is not conducive to the public good."
"After careful consideration, she [the Home Secretary] personally directed that you should be excluded from the United Kingdom on the grounds that your presence here is not conducive to the public good."
Furthermore,
Timothy Martin Burton was responsible for writing numerous blogs about TELL
MAMA and I on the virulently
anti-Muslim Liberty GB site which we have raised before. Further
information on the anti-Muslim Far Right Liberty GB site can be gained through this
link. Interestingly during one of his discussions on the Liberty GB site in
January 2014 with a Sheryl
McNaught whom TELL MAMA have highlighted
before, Timothy Martin Burton stated,
“Hi Sheryl, it's interesting that
TellMamaUK are monitoring your posts on this site. I'm going to make sure Fiyaz
Mughal gets his clock cleaned over his fraudulent and mendacious activities. By
the time this trial is over his name is going to be mud throughout the world…………… Of course Liberty GB is in no way
racist or Islamophobic, so if you wish to continue posting here then feel free,
there's nothing TellMamaUK can do about it.”
Australian Pals
One of
Timothy Martin Burton’s Australian pals is a Mike Holt of
Restore Australia. A read of this bizarre and vitriolic twisted site with its
deeply anti-Muslim views is not only stomach churning, it demonstrates the
on-line virulently anti-Muslim connections that Timothy Martin Burton had built
up. So coming back full circle to the earlier statement that Timothy Martin
Burton made of circulating this material far and wide, this is a brief example
of what Burton wanted to circulate written by the bizarre Mike Holt:
“If Islam was not in the UK……… he (Fiyaz Mughal) would not be
standing on his two hind legs to bleat about an insult that called him such
terrible names as mendacious grievance mongering taqqiyya (sic) artist, and a
lying Muslim scumbag.”
This
small segment of this virulently twisted and hate filled blog showed who Timothy
Martin Burton connected with and who he had reached out to for support. (Interestingly, so buoyed up is Timothy Martin Burton that he has set up his own Wikipedia Page that can be found here. Interestingly, the person who set it up - is a certain Timothy Martin Burton).
The Verdict
On
Tuesday the 8th of April 2014, after 2 hours of cross-examining by
the solicitor of Timothy Martin Burton and after completely rebutting a
confused and bizarre defence put up by the solicitor, I learnt that the
defendant had been released. The judge stated that the CPS had not made its case on the racially aggravated harassment charges. Yet, what is worrying is that this case was less about race and more about my perceived religious background as the language and terminology shows.
One of
these reasons the case failed, was because a Crown Prosecution Service who even with all of the
information provided by us, could not make the case. Furthermore, this case was
also based on the use of the term
taqiyya which we have listed before and which the CPS did not back up with
further specialist testimony or evidence. It also felt to me that the CPS was struggling to fully make the case on the terminology of anti-Muslim hate terms used - taqiyya in this case, (and given the background of Timothy Martin Burton and his links to Far Right groups), the context of the hate was clear.
On the
issue of the term ‘taqiyya’, two years of work on anti-Muslim
language and rhetoric shows that the frequency of the word is significant in
anti-Muslim rhetoric targeted at Muslims as
this article show. The CPS did miss out on the network and connections that Timothy Martin Burton had with Far Right sites and the lesson from this case is that much more work needs to be done on understanding the language of anti-Muslim hate. (Whilst, I can move on from this experience, what would the impact of such a verdict have on a Muslim visible female for example, and how would it make her feel about others or non-Muslims even).
Last but
not least, what message does the verdict send out to British Muslims who may be
targeted and called 'taqiyya' (lying because of their faith) Muslim scumbags?
More than ever, what this case shows is that the CPS and its understanding of
language around anti-Muslim hate lags well behind where things are today. Saying that, I will continue to work with
the CPS since this is the way to ensure real change for victims who suffer
targeted hate and intimidation. If we can make any changes to reduce and
alleviate their suffering, then all of this would have been worth it and I am a
firm believer that changes takes time and that consistency, tenacity and strong
evidence builds that change. I also believe in State institutions and whilst I
did not achieve the justice that I wanted, no doubt, change is coming and it is
on the horizon.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)